The Benner Cycle is one of the most popular trading methods based on stock market cycle theory. It is a well-known model for chart forecasting. Today, many similar theories exist, but proponents believe the Benner Cycle is more accurate, noting that it has been used to predict major events for more than 150 years.
This model can forecast long-term trades. In addition, the method is applied in wave analysis when a 5–10-year forecast is required.
A trading strategy based on market cycles can help traders generate steady long-term profits. This article explains how to use this method effectively in trading.
The article covers the following subjects:
- Major Takeaways
- Who Was Samuel Benner and Why Did He Create This Chart?
- Benner Cycle Chart Explained: What the Chart Basically Tells Investors
- The Three Mathematical Cycles Behind the Samuel Benner Chart
- How Accurate Is the Benner Cycle? Historical Evidence
- Should Traders Use the Benner Cycle Today?
- Conclusion
- FAQs
Major Takeaways
What Is the Benner Cycle? | The Benner Cycle is an economic development model based on alternating periods of growth and decline. According to the model, periods of optimism are followed by downturns fairly regularly, with the cycle repeating approximately every 30 years. |
Three Phases of the Benner Market Cycle | The first phase is accumulation, when investors buy assets at market lows. The second phase is growth, when prices rise and generate profits. The third phase is distribution, when positions are closed, and the market prepares for a decline. |
When Is the Best Time to Buy? | According to the model, assets are best bought during the accumulation phase, when markets are at their lows. During this period, large investors begin buying assets in anticipation of further growth. |
When Is the Best Time to Sell? | Assets are best sold during the distribution phase, when the market is overbought. During this period, large investors make money by selling assets to other market participants. |
How Accurate Is the Benner Cycle? | In today's market environment, the Benner Cycle is more of a forecasting model than a Smart Money trading strategy. It points to potential shifts in market sentiment, although the timing and magnitude of market fluctuations depend largely on external factors. Therefore, the Benner Cycle should be viewed more as a broad market guide than as an indicator. |
Is the Benner Cycle Still Relevant Today? | The model is still used as an additional indicator. It helps assess market sentiment and identify potential inflection points in major market trends. However, using it as a standalone strategy makes sense only for a very long-term investment horizon. |
Who Was Samuel Benner and Why Did He Create This Chart?
Most traders know that market prices move in waves, rising and falling over time. To achieve consistent results, you need to identify market cycles in advance. Around 150 years ago, American pig farmer Samuel Benner illustrated this pattern in a chart. After going bankrupt, he created the Samuel Benner cycle chart, which describes market cycles and is still used today.
Samuel Benner was not a professional financier or economics professor. This hog farmer lived in Ohio, where he farmed, grew corn, and raised livestock. His farm provided a steady income until a severe financial crisis broke out in the US in 1873, later known as the Panic of 1873. The banking panic of 1873 led to a contraction in lending and a decline in demand for agricultural products, while Benner's farm was also hit by hog cholera. As a result, he lost his property and fell into debt.
Many people in this situation would have simply given up, but Benner decided to understand what was happening and find out why commodity prices sometimes rose rapidly and then fell sharply, driving producers out of business.
After losing his farm, he began studying historical data. Benner compared prices for pig iron, corn, and hogs, looking for secret patterns. In 1875, he published a book arguing that crises did not occur randomly. In his view, price movements followed nature's cycles, including solar cycles. These ideas formed the basis of Benner's original cycle.
Benner Cycle Chart Explained: What the Chart Basically Tells Investors
The Benner cycle chart is a diagram of market cycles projected many decades into the future. Unlike conventional indicators based on current and historical data, the Benner cycle chart shows periods when market conditions are expected to change. The chart basically tells investors when profit opportunities may rise and when it may be better to preserve capital.
On the chart, Benner identified three levels corresponding to three market conditions and three phases of capital redistribution. Essentially, it is a stock market cycle chart covering long time intervals.
The upper level represents periods of peak market excitement, or panic years. The middle level corresponds to peak prices — favorable times for business. The lower level represents periods of severe economic downturn, or hard times (low prices). Benner labeled these levels A, B, and C. Each indicates a suggested action for traders during the corresponding period: buy stocks, sell stocks, or keep cash in their accounts.
A — Panic Years
Zone A is located at the top of the chart. These are the panic years. During this period, market optimism peaks. News reports increasingly focus on easy ways to make money. Inexperienced investors take out loans, use maximum leverage, and buy assets that have already risen sharply in price. At the same time, large funds sell their assets to other market participants.
When new money dries up, prices may fall sharply. Losing positions are forcibly closed, and asset prices decline significantly. In his book, Benner warned about the risks of holding assets during such periods. This is a key signal of the Benner Cycle: according to the model, traders should exit their positions at the peak.
For traders, this signals caution. Buying assets at peak prices can be a risky business. It may be better to close long positions, keep available funds in the account, or cautiously open short positions after a reversal is confirmed.
B — Good Times to Make Money (High Prices, Time to Sell)
Level B represents good times (high prices). The economy is growing, businesses are receiving more orders, companies are reporting high earnings, and experts expect further growth.
All the signs may suggest that investors should continue buying assets. However, Samuel Benner suggested a different approach. Phase B involves selling securities and commodities and taking profits, at least partially. According to Benner, these are periods when to make money by selling assets bought earlier during the downturn.
At this point, beginners face a major psychological challenge. When the market is rising, it can be difficult to close a profitable trade. Greed encourages traders to wait longer because they expect prices to rise even more. However, professional traders and large market participants may gradually reduce their positions during this period. Understanding market cycle theory helps them choose the right time to exit.
In the real market, when phase B begins, I recommend setting protective stop orders, such as a trailing stop, gradually moving them up as the price rises, and partially closing the position. There is no need to try to capture the last few points of a move: the potential extra profit may not justify the risk of losing profits already made. Boom and bust periods follow one another, so a trader's goal is to exit the position before the stock market crashes.
C — Hard Times (Low Prices, Time to Buy)
Level C represents hard times (low prices). This is a period of economic decline, falling production, high unemployment, and commodity price lows. The media is full of reports about economic problems. Many retail investors become disappointed with trading as they see their assets wiped out. These are gloomy days for global stock markets, with pessimism prevailing among market participants. Does this sound familiar? We saw a similar period quite recently.
Professional traders often call this phase an accumulation period. Large market participants may gradually buy cheaper assets from investors selling in panic. According to Benner's rule, stocks, real estate, and commodities should be bought during phase C and held until the next period of economic growth. Benner Cycle accuracy in identifying such turning points has not been proven, so the model should be used as a general guide rather than an exact forecast.
Buying securities when panic and fear dominate the market can be psychologically difficult. It requires a calm approach and strict capital management. It is better to buy assets gradually in small amounts and avoid excessive leverage. This approach helps limit risk and is consistent with risk management principles for long-term investing.
The Three Mathematical Cycles Behind the Samuel Benner Chart
Benner based his market-cycle theory on historical data and recurring time sequences. The cycle identifies moves based on three recurring sequences associated with panics, high prices, and low prices. To understand how the overall Benner Cycle works, consider each sequence separately.
Pig Iron Price Cycle: 8, 9, 10 Years and 11, 9, 7 Years
In the 19th century, pig iron was an important industrial commodity, and its price movements reflected the state of industry. By analyzing pig iron prices, Benner identified a pattern. According to his observations, periods of peak prices occurred at intervals of 8, 9, and 10 years, after which the sequence started again. Low prices occurred at intervals of 11, 9, and 7 years.
The intervals in each sequence add up to 27 years. Thus, in Benner's model, pig iron prices followed a 27-year cycle.
Agricultural Cycle: 5–6-Year Cycles in Corn and Pig Prices
Benner's second observation concerned agricultural goods. He tracked grain and hog prices and tried to explain their periodic fluctuations through natural factors, including the 11-year solar cycle. According to his observations, crop yields were a key factor affecting agricultural supply and, therefore, prices. High and low prices alternated, creating recurring intervals. Good and poor harvests affected supply, causing ups and downs in grain prices.
Panic Cycle: Financial Crises Every 16, 18, and 20 Years
Benner's third cycle describes the recurrence of financial panics. After analyzing past crises, Benner suggested that the intervals between these events followed a 16-, 18-, and 20-year sequence.
Together, these intervals form a 54-year sequence, after which the pattern repeats. Thus, in Benner's model, the full stock market cycle associated with financial panics spans 54 years.
How Accurate Is the Benner Cycle? Historical Evidence
Any trading strategy or theory should be tested against historical data. Comparing Benner's forecasts with actual crises of the 20th and 21st centuries reveals some matches that seem surprisingly accurate. However, these matches alone do not prove the model's predictive accuracy.
Notable Matches: The Great Depression, the Dot-Com Crash, and the 2008 Crisis
One of the best-known matches is associated with the events of 1929. This period was close to a crisis zone on the Benner cycle chart. In autumn 1929, the US stock market crashed, and the economic downturn that followed developed into the Great Depression. The 1929 stock market crash was one of the largest in US market history.
The decline continued in the following years. In July 1932, the Dow Jones reached its low, losing about 89% from its 1929 peak. For long-term investors, low prices created opportunities to buy assets.
Another example can be found in the events of 1999–2000. This period was also close to one of the crisis zones on the Benner cycle chart. In 2000, the dot-com bubble began to burst, and the Nasdaq Composite subsequently lost about 78% from its peak.
Some modern versions of the chart also mark 2007 as a period of high prices. The US mortgage crisis began in 2007 and developed into the 2008 financial crisis. These matches are often cited as examples of the Benner model aligning with actual market events, but they do not, by themselves, prove its predictive accuracy.
Where the Model Falls Short: Fed Intervention and Shifts in Timing
Despite some notable matches, the Benner model does not always correspond to actual market movements. For example, the Benner cycle chart indicated a period of low prices around 2012. In reality, financial markets bottomed after the mortgage crisis about three years earlier. The S&P 500 reached its low in March 2009, falling to around 677 points.
There are a few reasons for this shift in timing, including the evolution of economic regulation. The US Federal Reserve did not yet exist in Benner's time, and modern monetary policy tools were not used. Central banks and financial authorities can influence the duration of economic downturns and recoveries, changing market dynamics. In addition, the Second World War and the recovery that followed had a major impact on the global economy and may have disrupted the proposed cyclical pattern.
Should Traders Use the Benner Cycle Today?
Should investors today make decisions based solely on a calendar created 150 years ago? Rationally speaking, of course not. Trading exclusively on historical cycles to navigate unpredictable markets without considering current conditions involves a high level of risk. However, the Benner model can still be useful today as an additional reference point.
Using Cycles in Medium-Term Trading
Use the Benner cycle chart to assess the overall market environment on higher time frames, from weekly to monthly. This can help identify future ups and downs and determine the direction of the main trend.
If the model indicates phase C, traders can focus on finding reliable buy signals. According to the model, this phase may be followed by future prosperity that supports asset price growth.
Use technical analysis to determine the right time to enter a trade. Wait for signs that the decline is ending on the daily chart, track buy and sell signals using indicators such as the RSI or MACD, and assess market activity based on trading volume. Market cycles help determine the overall direction, while technical analysis helps identify entry and exit points. Similar patterns were also studied by George Tritch, who further developed Benner's ideas.
Key Risk Management Rules for Beginners
When using long-term strategies, remember that no forecast can guarantee a profit. Trading results depend not only on the strategy but also on proper risk management. Even considering the supposed accuracy of the Benner Cycle and Benner's prophecies of future, traders should always be prepared for rapid changes in market conditions.
The main rule is not to risk all your capital. It is generally recommended to limit the risk on a single trade to 1–2% of your account balance. Set a stop-loss when opening a position to limit potential losses if the price moves against you. This is a basic principle of proper risk management.
Another rule is to take profits gradually during periods of high prices rather than waiting for a complete market reversal. Do not try to catch the absolute peak at the risk of losing profits you have already made.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Benner Cycle can be used as an additional tool for long-term market analysis. It can help traders assess long-term market trends and adjust their financial plan. In swing trading, Benner's theory can also serve as an additional guide for identifying broader market trends.
Samuel Benner suggested that markets move in cycles, which he linked, among other things, to recurring human emotions such as greed and fear. To achieve positive results, traders need to understand the broader market picture, act cautiously, and maintain trading discipline. However, traders should not treat the cycle's key points as completely reliable signals, since their accuracy depends on many factors.
FAQs
Samuel Benner began developing his theory after going bankrupt during the Panic of 1873. He tried to understand what had happened and observed that pig iron and agricultural commodity prices changed at recurring intervals.
The Benner Cycle coincides with some major financial crashes, including the Great Depression, the dot-com crash, and the 2008 global financial crisis. However, these coincidences should not be considered exact predictions. The model was created long before modern stock indices appeared, and its predictive accuracy has not been proven.
According to some modern interpretations of Benner's prophecies of future, 2026 corresponds to a period of high prices. For long-term investors, this may be a reason to be more cautious and reconsider their long positions. However, the model cannot reliably predict that a downturn will necessarily follow and continue through 2030.
The content of this article reflects the author’s opinion and does not necessarily reflect the official position of LiteFinance broker. The material published on this page is provided for informational purposes only and should not be considered as the provision of investment advice for the purposes of Directive 2014/65/EU.
According to copyright law, this article is considered intellectual property, which includes a prohibition on copying and distributing it without consent.
